I mean, we all knew it was coming, but man! With the whole 'Mo retiring' thing, now we have another big time Yankee star leaving t...

  December 2006: Will Andy Sign? Yes, back to Yanks. December 2008: Is Andy coming back? Yes. December 2009: Is Andy coming back? Y...

  I don't think that Andy Pettite is a Hall of Famer. I mean, if he does get in, it won't be immediately. He's under apprec...

I feel like every five years Andy Pettite returns to the Yankees. Fitting, too. Back in 2007 we were a force to reckon with in the AL. Back ...

You may not be headed to Cooperstown, but the Bronx will remember you for years to come. Thanks for 12 decent seasons...and for not retirin...

Knock those Twins down Show those Reds how we do it down here.

Andy Pettite said he would retire at the end of the 2009 season. Then he signed with the Yankees again. Andy once again said last year that ...

I'm so sorry, but I have a feeling that this guy might not be a world friggin champion anymore Hope you can settle for this guy I mean,...