A little while before the playoffs, I wrote a post about the Dodgers and Astros having subpar quality teams for their regime, owing mostly to pitching injuries. The Astros were going with lesser seasons from most of their regulars, a shruggingly existent youth core, and a rotation of people getting by simply because they were the Astros. And I said that they didn't deserve being handed postseason glory again.
The fact that in the early rungs of the postseason, the Dodgers were nearly eliminated and hit an incredible second wind to take it all while the Astros got bodied by the Tigers before October was really underway is honestly incredible. I was right about one of those teams, and it was the Astros. This was not the team, and they weren't gonna shove themselves into a playoff picture that had no room for them this year.
Needless to say that worked for me. Didn't have to see teams struggle to figure out a team with obvious flaws. Breathed easier.
After sending Martin Maldonado to a team that matches his mediocrity, the Astros got a new backup in Victor Caratini, who's made the postseason with practically every team he's ever played for, and has caught no-hitters from the best. Caratini, unsurprisingly, had another steady season there, and it was in fact his best statistical season to date, with a 1.3 WAR. In 87 games he hit .269 with 8 home runs and 30 RBIs, and was an above-average backstop. With Yainer Diaz being a more offense-friendly catching option, having Caratini as a backup that can play more often, and swap in at C to give Diaz a start at DH, is a great thing, and hopefully he'll deliver a similar season in 2025.
Folks, in our 20th season of Justin Verlander, we finally landed upon a sight we'd rarely ever seen with the future Hall of Famer, and that is human, beatable JV. The veteran made 17 starts this year, and thanks to both injuries and his age, teams were able to figure him out more than usual this year. JV went 5-6 with a 5.48 ERA and 74 Ks. For the first time since his rookie year in 2005, Verlander ended the year with a negative WAR. Yet despite this, Verlander seems to have no plans to retire yet. He'll be 42 next year, and at the very least he'll be back from whatever injuries were holding him back this year. If anything, it's good for baseball if he does suit up for somebody.
I didn't understand the mentality that led to the Astros trading Joey Loperfido and Jake Bloss, two guys who were actually working their way toward aiding the Astros as they competed, and Will Wagner, someone who was league ready and would prove it in Toronto, for Yusei Kikuchi, who'd been terrible in his last ten starts and had established community with the team. And yet, because the Astros' GM always seems to know more than anyone else, this paid off: Kikuchi was wonderful in 10 starts with the Astros, going 5-1 with a 2.70 ERA and 76 Ks, more than Justin Verlander in nearly double the games. Between Kikuchi, Arrighetti, Brown and Valdez, the Astros really capitalized off of the strikeout this year.
Here's the oddest sight of the year for this team: Jason Heyward, who was very close to competing for a ring this year in LA, was cut in August and picked up by Houston, despite interest from Atlanta. And so we have this...very usual combination, this stage of Heyward's career and this stage of Astros baseball. J-Hey was okay for the 'Stros, he had 4 homers and 9 RBIs in 24 games, and this was a bit more energized than he was for the Dodgers, but he wasn't exactly a key contributor to the postseason team.
























