The Giants, like usual, had some strong swells, some embarrassing swells, some great performances, some disappointing performances, and some ultimate harsh realities. Bob Melvin in San Francisco did not work, much like Gabe Kapler did not work. The idea seems to be that getting a new breed of MLB manager in Tony Vitello, being the first to make the common-for-football jump from college coach to professional skipper. Now, the NFL has proved that this sort of thing can work sometimes [Pete Carroll, Jim Harbaugh] and fail loads of other times [Urban Meyer, Chip Kelly, Lane Kiffin, Matt Rhule, Nick Saban, how long ya got??]. But the Giants are confident. They were confident with Melvin but somehow they're more confident now. The right team doesn't seem to be terribly far away, it just needs the right circumstances.
Like, for instance, Patrick Bailey came up being so good in multiple facets that the Giants felt they could trade Joey Bart. And then Bailey mellowed out and now Bart hits better in Pittsburgh. In 2025, Bailey won his second straight gold glove behind the plate. He also hit .222, his lowest average yet, despite 55 RBIs, his highest total yet. Clearly the offense isn't gonna be the takeaway, unless he undergoes a Salvy Perez-esque transformation, but he's still a great defensive weapon and he's good for the occasional power moment.
2026 Prediction: All-star nod. He will not be the initial choice but somebody'll get injured and there'll be an opening.
Speaking of the all-star game, Randy Rodriguez, a 25-year-old second year reliever, did the unthinkable by making an ASG team despite nobody really having heard of him. Dave Roberts, in putting the roster together, knew he needed a great relief weapon, and given the amount of times he had to manage around Rodriguez he thought the kid invaluable. In 50 games, Rodriguez had a 1.78 ERA with 67 strikeouts, a .888 WHIP and a 1.9 WAR. He got hurt a little after the break and may be out for a while, but if the Giants can sustain his success they might be alright.
2026 Prediction: Does not appear.
2027 Prediction: Yeah, more of this kind of low-ERA dominance.
The Giants usual relief specialist extraordinaire, Ryan Walker, was thrust into the RP1 role when Camilo Doval and Tyler Rogers got traded. Walker was terrific in 2024, and was slightly shakier this year, with a 4.11 ERA, a 5-7 record, 60 Ks and, importantly, 17 saves. He can, and will, be relied upon to close games, and hopefully that'll straighten things out. Also, I learned recently that Ryan Walker and I share the same birthday, to the year. He turned the big 3-0 on the 26th of November. Don't, uh, don't look at me like that.
2026 Prediction: 30+ saves, and more eyes on him.
Though the Giants had their rotation figured out from the jump for the most part, between Logan Webb, Robbie Ray, Justin Verlander and Jordan Hicks, they called upon Landen Roupp, over Kyle Harrison and Hayden Birdsong, and quickly the Giants fans understood why. Roupp was pretty impressive in a relatively full season of work, with a 3.80 ERA and 102 Ks in 22 starts. Not Webb levels, but a sturdy, reliable low starter. In August he took a liner to the leg, got a bone bruise and was out the rest of the year.
2026 Prediction: Is back in full force, takes a bit more of a load and has his best season to date.
Dominic Smith was in camp with the Yankees, and was honestly hitting like crazy, making the Yankees' eventual decision to cut him over Ben Rice puzzling until...until we saw what Rice was cooking. So Smith eventually signed a minor league deal with the Giants, then made the team when LaMonte Wade trailed off. It was slightly risky stacking this team with three corner infielders who aren't good on defense, but Smith made up for it with some strong hitting, hitting .284 in 63 games, with 5 homers, 33 RBIs, and a .750 OPS.
2026 Prediction: Similar bench/replacement role with a smaller market team.
And then as it became clear that Tyler Fitzgerald wasn't gonna be homer-crazy like he was last year, and therefore wasn't useful, the Giants turned to Christian Koss as the everyday second baseman. Koss was not only a defensive upgrade from Fitzgerald, but he hit .264. Like Bailey the defense is the difference-maker with Koss, but he's got the occasional contact perk to help out.
2026 Prediction: He'll be more of a utility guy I gather, as I'm thinking the Giants will try and get an upgrade at 2B, but he'll still be extremely useful, especially as this team attempts a playoff berth.
Coming Tomorrow- The Guardians made the playoffs without their closer, and with the division leaders being two weeks ahead of them in August. There's still some magic in this team after all.
No comments:
Post a Comment